<< Archive Articles

ERRATA

When Stars Collide Endnotes

Some copies of When Stars Collide were distributed with misprinted endnotes. Here are the correctly numbered endnotes.

 

i Private Lives by Noel Coward, A study guide prepared by Martin Andrucki, Charles A. Dana Professor of Theater Bates College http://www.thepublictheatre.org/stdygds/private_lives_study_guide_03_04.htm

ii People born between 23 rd May and 21 st June have the Sun is in Gemini, while those born between 24 th July and 23 rd August have the Sun in Leo. Depending in the year in question, the start and end dates of all the Sun signs varies slightly, but there is no such thing as "being born on the cusp so you're a bit of both" - you are either one or the other.

iii 920 out of 1300 relationships have a close trine, conjunction or opposition of the planet Venus to either the Sun, Venus or Mars in their partner's natal or progressed chart

iv See Chapters Fifteen and Sixteen for more on this issue.

v I later found that another astrologer was writing about the same idea at about the same time. Robert Blaschke wrote about synastric progressions in 1997 in Astrology: A Language of Life Volume 1- Progressions, Earthwalk School of Astrology, 1997, p79

vi Interestingly, two squares between the Sun and Venus formed between the progressed and natal horoscopes of Princess Margaret and Peter Townshend between 1950 and 1956.

vii Many of the celebrities dates and times of birth included in this study are also included in Astrodatabank, it is difficult, however, to always match couples whose times of birth are known for certain. In this respect I have had to find a large number of individual dates from other sources, these have included online resources including IMDB.com, findagrave.com, the Encyclopedia Britannica, internet newsgroups and other miscellaneous web pages. The accuracy of dates of birth in IMDB.com is questionable in some cases, but it is very useful as a resource to find out who individual celebrities were married to and when these marriages took place. There is however a point at which IMDB becomes the only resource for relatively obscure individuals dates of birth and so this is possibly the weakest (while also one of the most useful) links in this study. Every date of birth has been checked for dispute or inaccuracy. Those that are under dispute have been rejected.

viii Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships, AFA, 1958, p11

ix ibid p11

x ibid p11

xi ibid p11

xii Garth Fletcher, The New Science of Intimate Relationships , Blackwell, 2002, p101

xiii It should be noted that there are many harmonic aspects (divisions of the zodiacal circle) other than the seven mentioned in this book and as such aspects of 36, 40, 45, 51, 72, 80, 102, 135 and 144 degrees and others may also have important roles to play in the intimate connections of the Sun, Venus and Mars.

xiv Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations through Astrology , Aurora , 1983, p7

xv ibid , p8

xvi David Plant Johannes Kepler And the Music of the Spheres , Traditional Astrologer magazine, summer 1995

xvii ibid

xviii John Anthony West, The Case for Astrology , Viking, 1991, p171

xix David Plant Johannes Kepler And the Music of the Spheres , Traditional Astrologer magazine, summer 1995

(Of these Keplerian aspects, I have come to regard the 72° Quintile as a favourable relationship indicator, but I have not yet subjected this aspect to large-scale quantitative scrutiny)

xx Arthur M Young (1905 - 1995) was the inventor of the Bell Helicopter.

xxi Nancy Hastings, Secondary Progressions Weiser, 1984, foreword by Rob Hand, p ix

xxii Bernadette Brady, Predictive Astrology, The Eagle and the Lark , Weiser, 1999, p100-101

xxiii Stephen Arroyo, Astrology, Karma and Transformation , CRCS, 1992, p167

xxiv Charles E.O Carter, The Principles of Astrology

xxv Robert P Blaschke, Astrology: A Language of Life Volume 1- Progressions, Earthwalk School of Astrology, 1997, p5

xxvi Martin Freeman, Forecasting by Astrology , Aquarian Press, 1982, p35

xxvii Eric Francis quoted from an article here: http://www.cainer.com/ericfrancis/aug20.html

xxviii Dane Rudhyar, The Astrology of Personality , Aurora, 1991, p336

xxix Laurie Efrein, How to Rectify a Birth Chart , Aquarian Press, 1987, p166

xxx Placidus de Titus' book Primum Mobile was originally published in 1657 and translated (1994) by Michael Baigent. Garry Phillipson also quotes Henry Coley from a manuscript in the British Library Sloan Ms2280 p.5, in the context of a chart interpretation which begins 'The nativity of Madam Eliz. Hope don by Dr Oznoy anno 1690'. 'and the Ascend to the square of Mercury at the very same time according to (?) this (?) way of Direction us'd by Placidus de Titus a monk, about the year 1655'

xxxi On page 164 of his book, A History of Horoscopic Astrology (AFA). James Holden writes:

"[Kepler] is also said to have considered that the number of days after birth that the Sun took to reach a natal planet was equivalent to the number of years of the native's life that would lapse before the indicated influence would manifest itself. This is the earliest instance I have encountered of the use of what we would call a secondary direction"

xxxii The modern Western use of progressed aspects demands that they have a limited influence in terms of time based on the type of aspect. Traditionalists apply different orbs depending on the planets involved .

xxxiii Eric Francis, quoted from an article here: http://www.cainer.com/ericfrancis/aug20.html

xxxiv Adrian Duncan, Doing Time on Planet Earth , Element, 1990, p39

xxxv Robert Hand, Horoscope Symbols , Whitford Press, 1981

xxxvi Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997

xxxvii Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983

xxxviii Frances Sakoian and Louis S. Acker, The Astrology of Human Relationships , Peter Davies, 1976

xxxix Stephen Arroyo, Relationships and Life Cycles , CRCS, 1993

xl Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p49

xli ibid p49

xlii Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983, p101

xliii Stephen Arroyo, Relationships and Life Cycles , CRCS, 1993, p90

xliv Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p50

xlv ibid p50

xlvi ibid p69

xlvii Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983, p127

xlviii Sheridan Morley, The Other Side of the Moon , Coronet, 1986, p162

xlix David Niven and Primula Rollo's relationship is not included in the 1300 relationships

l Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p70

li The relationship of Shah Jahan and Mumtaz Mahal is not included in the 1300 relationships

lii Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p69

liii Mia Farrow, What Falls Away , Doubleday, 1997, p120

liv ibid p70

lv ibid p74

lvi ibid p75

lvii Stephen Arroyo, Relationships and Life Cycles , CRCS, 1993, p91-92

lviii Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p69

lix ibid p51

lx Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983, p105

lxi Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p52

lxii ibid p52iii

lxiii ibid p52

lxiv ibid p52

lxv ibid p52-53

lxvi ibid p52

lxvii ibid p53

lxviii ibid p70

lxix Frances Sakoian and Louis S. Acker, The Astrology of Human Relationships , Peter Davies, 1976, p170

lxx Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983, p127-129

lxxi Lois Haines Sargent, How to Handle your Human Relationships , AFA, 1997, p70

lxxii ibid p70

lxxiii Frances Sakoian and Louis S. Acker, The Astrology of Human Relationships , Peter Davies, 1976, p184

lxxiv Ronald Davison, Synastry - Understanding Human Relations Through Astrology , Aurora Press, 1983, p127-129

lxxv Stephen Arroyo, Relationships and Life Cycles , CRCS, 1993, p87

lxxvi Barry Norman, The Hollywood Greats , BBC Books, 1980, p180

lxxvii Mary Wollstonecraft, A Vindication of the Rights of Women , The full Etext can be found on this web site: http://womenshistory.about.com/library/etext/bl_vindication000.htm

lxxviii The relationship of George Sand and Casimir Dudevant is not included in the 1300 relationships

lxxia Belinda Jack, George Sand A Women's Life Writ Large , Vintage, 2001, p110

lxxx George Sand, Deuvres autobiographique vol II (ed George Lubin), p27

lxxxi Belinda Jack, George Sand A Women's Life Writ Large , Vintage, 2001, p113

lxxxii ibid , p117

lxxxiii ibid , p157

lxxxiv George Sand, Correspondence, quoted in Jack, p157

lxxxv Belinda Jack, George Sand A Women's Life Writ Large , Vintage, 2001, p212

lxxxvi ibid, p217

lxxxvii The relationship of George Sand and Marie Dorval is not included in the 1300 relationships

lxxxviii George Sand, Correspondence, quoted in Jack, p220

lxxxix Belinda Jack, George Sand A Women's Life Writ Large , Vintage, 2001, p221

xc Alfred de Musset, quoted in Rene Doumic, Biography of George Sand, http://www.worldwideschool.org/library/books/hst/biography/BiographyofGeorgeSand/chap6.html

xci Belinda Jack, George Sand A Women's Life Writ Large , Vintage, 2001, p248

xcii George Sand, Deuvres autobiographique vol II (ed George Lubin), p322

xciii http://perso.wanadoo.fr/negrel/hommes/michel_de_bourges.htm

xciv Marion D March and Joan McEvers, The Only Way to Learn About Relationships , ACS, 1992, p94

xcv The relationship of George Sand and Louis Blanc is not included in the 1300 relationships

xcvi James Spada, Grace, The Secret Lives of a Princess , Penguin, 1988, p48

xcvii The relationship of Grace Kelly and Mark Miller is not included in the 1300 relationships

xcviii James Spada, Grace, The Secret Lives of a Princess , Penguin, 1988, p76

xcix Robert Lacey, Grace , G.P. Putnam & Sons, 1994, p157

c ibid, p157

ci C. David Heymann, Liz - An Intimate Biography of Elizabeth Taylor , Mandarin, 1996, p108-109

cii ibid, p109

ciii ibid, p132

civ Michael Todd Jr. and Susan McCarthy Todd, A Valuable Property - The Life Story of Michael Todd, Arbor House, 1983, p13

cv Kitty Kelley, Elizabeth Taylor - The Last Star , BCA, 1981, p101

cvi Eddie Fisher with David Fisher, Been There, Done That , Arrow, 1999, p158-159

cvii ibid , p180

cviii C. David Heymann, Liz - An Intimate Biography of Elizabeth Taylor , Mandarin, 1996 , p279

cxix The relationship of Richard Burton and Sybil Williams is not included in the 1300 relationships

cx The relationship of Richard Burton and Claire Bloom is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxi The relationship of Richard Burton and Susan Strasberg is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxii C. David Heymann, Liz - An Intimate Biography of Elizabeth Taylor , Mandarin, 1996 , p279 (the actual word used in this declaration was 'nailed' not 'made love to')

cxiii Graham Jenkins, Richard Burton My Brother , Sphere Books, 1988, p304-305

cxiv The relationship of Richard Burton and Princess Elizabeth of Yugoslavia is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxv The relationship of Richard Burton and Sally Hay is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxvi the 2004 Carter Memorial Lecture delivered by Dr. Patrick Curry http://www.skyscript.co.uk/enchantment.html

cxvii Chapter two of the first tractate of Guido Bonatti's Liber Astronomiae (written in the thirteenth Century CE) is entitled That the Stars Imprint [their influences] on Inferior Bodies and that the Mutations Which Happen in This World Happen by the Motion of the Stars . In this chapter, Bonatti explains that the circular motion of the heavens causes change on Earth and that because the Sun and Moon are closer to the Earth, their presence is felt more than the impressions made by the other planets and stars. Of course, Bonatti firstly ascribed cause to the divinity of God and secondly to the motion of heavenly objects. In essence he is describing physical causality subject to a divine will.

cxviii Edwin Abbott, Flatland, A Romance in Many Dimensions , Penguin, 1999

cxix For further information see Roger Penrose, Shadows of the Mind, Vintage, 1995

cxx John Anthony West, The Case for Astrology , Viking, 1991, p173 - 175

cxxi Dante Alghieri, La Vita Nuova, XXI, translated by Dante Gabriel Rossetti

cxxii Eddie Cochran and Sharon Sheeley, Somethin' Else

cxxiii The Saturn return takes place between the ages of 29 and 31 years depending on the motion of Saturn. It happens when the planet of responsibility and achievement returns to the position in the chart it occupied when the subject was born. Many people change jobs, relationship or lifestyle at this point in their lives as Saturn holds a proverbial mirror up to their life and asks them whether the direction in which they are travelling is the right one for them.

cxxiv Neil Spencer, True As The Stars Above , Orion, 2000, p230

cxxv ibid , p231

cxxvi Martin Seymour-Smith, Robert Graves - His Life and Work , , 1983, p314

cxxvii ibid p317

cxxviii ibid p317

cxxix Colin Wilson, The Occult , Grafton, 1979, p477

cxxx http://www.maypang.com/bio.html

cxxxi The relationship of Ringo Starr and Maureen Cox is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxxxii The relationship of Stuart Sutcliffe and Astrid Kirscherr is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxxxiii The relationship of David and Angie Bowie is not included in the 1300 relationships. Angie's date of birth is not readily accessible in the public domain, but it is known that she celebrated her 25 th birthday on August 9 th 1974.

cxxxiv The relationship of Kylie Minogue and Rupert Penry-Jones is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxxxv Bob Geldof, Is That It? , Penguin, 1986, p153

cxxxvi Gerry Agar - Paula Michael and Bob - Everything You Know is Wrong , Michael O'Mara Books, 2003, p35

cxxxvii ibid , p51-52

cxxxviii Sharon Krum The Manhattan Interview, Sept 1997 available to view online at: http://www.thei.aust.com/music3/hutch9.html

cxxxix http://www.bobgeldof.info/interviews.htm

cxl The relationship of John Profumo and Valerie Hobson is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxli The relationship of John Mortimer and Wendy Craig is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxlii The relationship of John Mortimer and Penelope Fletcher is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxliii The relationship of Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxliv Jennifer Aniston has recently been linked with Vince Vaughan. They share a natal Sun natal Venus conjunction within two degrees.

cxlv This was the TV show which brought Katie Price (AKA Jordan ) together with singer Peter Andre. They share a progressed-Venus progressed-Mars opposition.

cxlvi The relationship of Bryan McFadden and Delta Goodrem is not included in the 1300 relationships

cxlvii Sam Kashner and Jennifer MacNair, The Bad and the Beautiful , WW Norton and Co, 2002, p199

cxlviii ibid p206

cxlix The relationship of Shirley Maclaine and Andrew Peacock is not included in the 1300 relationships

cl J.Randall Taraborelli, Sinatra, The Man Behind the Myth , Mainstream Publishing, 2001, p140

cli ibid , p146

clii ibid , p155

cliii ibid, p167

cliv ibid, p144

clv J Randall Taraborelli, Sinatra, the Man behind the Myth, Mainstream, p435

clvi ibid , p436

clvii Laurence Olivier, Confessions of an Actor , Coronet, 1983, p172

clviii The relationship of Vivien Leigh and Peter Finch is not included in the 1300 relationships

clix The relationship of Ellen Degeneres and Portia de Rossi is not included in the 1300 relationships

clx The relationship of Romaine Brooks and Natalie Barney is not included in the 1300 relationships

clxi The relationship of Benjamin Britten and Peter Pears is not included in the 1300 relationships

clxii The relationship of Christopher Isherwood and Don Bachardy is not included in the 1300 relationships

clxiii See this web page for an introduction to Arthur Young's ideas about progressions: http://www.arthuryoung.com/3time.html

clxiv Jodie and Steven Forrest, Skymates- Love Sex and Evolutionary Astrology , Seven Paws Press, 2002, p4

clxv The relationship of Rev. Billy Graham and Ruth Bell is not included in the 1300 relationships

clxvi Mormon Elder Bruce R.McConkie has this to say:[Astrology is a] form of divination and fortune telling akin to sorcery, astrology is a pseudo science that pretends to divulge the influence of the stars upon human affairs; it is a false science that claims to foretell earthly events by means of the positions and aspects of these heavenly luminaries. It is, of course, one of Satan's substitutes for the true science of astronomy and for the true principle of receiving revelation of future events from divine sources.

Ancient uninspired peoples were frequently deluded by the snares of the astrologers among them (Isa. 47; Dan. 1:20; 2:27; 4:7; 5:7), but it is difficult to understand why people in modern and supposedly enlightened and civilized nations should submit to these same stargazing absurdities. Enlightened people in and out of the Church shun them for the abominations they are. Mormon Doctrine, p.56

http://www.lightplanet.com/mormons/daily/prayer/improper_channels.htm

clxvii The relationships of Joseph Smith and Emma, Joseph Smith and Eliza Snow and Brigham Young and Eliza Snow are not included in the 1300 relationships.

 

clxviii Eddie Fisher with David Fisher, Been There, Done That , Arrow, 1999, p217-296

clxix It occurs twice in two relationships

clxx Of course, the other side of the coin is that this survey is in itself, incomplete. I have tested only the major astrological aspects. I acknowledge that most scientists would not accept my view as plain fact without considering all the other possible angles between planets.

clxxi The natal Venus natal Mars trine aspect hasn't featured - in isolation - in many of the relationships in this book. See the relationships of Burton and Elizabeth of Yugoslavia, Grace and Rainier, Rainier and Gisele Pascal and Grace and Cary Grant. It is present, although not in isolation, in the relationship of Prince William of Wales and Kate Middleton.

clxxii The progressed Venus progressed Mars trine was also present in the relationship of Elton John and David Furnish in 1993 when they met. This is not included in the 1300 relationships.

clxxiii The relationships of Carl Sagan with Lynn Margulis, Linda Saltzman and Anne Druyan are not included in the 1300 relationships

clxxiv The relationship of Charles Darwin and Emma Wedgwood is not included in the 1300 relationships. The progressed-Venus natal Mars conjunction occurs 38 times in this survey.

clxxv The relationship of Bart J. Bok and Priscilla Fairfield is not included in the 1300 relationships. For more information about Objections to Astrology see John Anthony West's The Case for Astrology.

clxxvi None of the following relationships are included in the 1300 relationships: Lenin and Krupskaya, Marx and von Westphalen or the Gorbachev's.

clxxvii The relationship of L. Sprague de Camp and Catherine Crook is not included in the 1300 relationships (progressed-Sun conjunction progressed-Venus)

clxxviii The relationships of Bertrand Russell with Ottoline Morrell, Constance Malleson, Dora Black, Edith Finch and Vivienne Eliot are not included in the 1300 relationships. His relationship with Constance Malleson contains a natal Venus progressed-Mars opposition, within one degree in 1915, this aspect does not occur enough times in the survey to be described as a strong indicator, whereas progressed-Venus opposite natal Mars does.

clxxix Bertrand Russell wrote the following in 1932: ' That [astrologers proliferation] should be possible is creditable to them but very discreditable to our educational system. In schools and universities information of all sorts is ladled out, but no one is taught to reason, or to consider what is evidence for what. To any person with even the vaguest idea of the nature of scientific evidence, such beliefs as those of astrologers are of course impossible. But so are most of the beliefs upon which governments are based, such as the peculiar merit of persons living in a certain area, or of persons whose income exceeds a certain sum. It would not do to teach people to reason correctly, since the result would be to undermine these beliefs. If these beliefs were to fade, mankind might escape disaster, but politicians could not. At all costs, therefore, we must be kept stupid.'

 

Matrices | Relationship Pages